HistoryofScience.com Blog

Sunday, August 17, 2008

Publisher accused of 'grave robbing' for printing last two novels marred by Sir Walter Scott's ill-health

As a specialist in rare books in the history of science and medicine for more than 40 years, I have handled numerous rare items concerning the history of resurrection men, also called resurrectionists, or body-snatchers. These pamphlets, broadsides, and books usually concern the business of illegally supplying corpses to anatomy schools in England and the United States during the early nineteenth century when criminals sentenced to be hanged and anatomized were the only legal supply of corpses, and this supply was insufficient to support the demand from private anatomy schools. The most notorious of all resurrectionists were Burke and Hare, who were able to supply fresh, undeteriorated corpses to the anatomist Robert Knox by smothering their victims. A hero of my youth, the poet Dylan Thomas, wrote a screenplay on this topic entitled The Doctor and the Devils, which was published in 1953. It was significantly re-written and produced as a film with the same title in 1985, starring Timothy Dalton, Jonathan Pryce, and of all actresses--Twiggy. In my opinion, this film is one of the most entertaining and authentic dramatizations relating to medical history. It is available on DVD.

While I have had a lot of business experience with rare material concerning resurrection men, I never imagined that a publisher could be accused of resurrecting a manuscript that rightly should have been left undisturbed in its archival grave. However, that is exactly what happened recently, according to a review published in Scotland on Sunday of Sir Walter Scott's posthumous The Siege of Malta and Bizarro. These unfinished novels were written by Scott in 1831 and 1832 after he had suffered a series of strokes which affected his writing abilities. Because of their obvious major flaws neither Scott nor his descendants believed that they should ever be published. "The late John Buchan read both works while researching a biography of Scott in 1932 and remarked: 'It may be hoped that no literary resurrectionist will ever be guilty of the crime of giving them to the world.' " For decades the manuscripts, with all their limitations, were preserved in the Berg Collection at the New York Public Library.

However history judges these literary "resurrectionists," and I suspect that it will be with tolerance--it should be pointed out that no professional body-snatcher ever wanted to be accused of actual "grave-robbing." That is because punishment for stealing a dead body was a misdemeanor, punishable with a fine or imprisonment, while actually stealing property from a corpse, such as jewelry that might have been buried with a body, was a felony, potentially punishable by "transportation" or even execution.

In keeping with our enlightened, tolerant view of this questionable publishing project, and not wanting the publisher to suffer more than appropriate critical ridicule, would we want to remove the words "grave-robbing" from the headline and revise it as follows: "Publisher Accused of Literary Body-Snatching for Printing Last Two Novels Marred by Sir Walter Scott's Ill-Health?"

posted by Jeremy Norman @ 11:20 AM   14 Comments


At June 15, 2018 at 12:07 AM , Blogger Chuyển Hàng Quốc Tế said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

At November 20, 2018 at 1:03 AM , Blogger anonymous said...

The music is everything and numerous individuals love the music. You present here every one of the urban areas where summer is accessible for the music and check out papersowl review for good task. The meaning of music is composed of sound and pitch. There are numerous things identified with music, and keeping in mind that there are justifiable social varieties, the properties of music are the properties.

At November 28, 2019 at 12:03 AM , Blogger Oliver Maurice said...

I think that you need to check out this blog post on how to become a good research paper writer or how to find yourself one to do your job for you. This could be useful

At February 4, 2020 at 6:44 PM , Blogger Andrea Pirlo said...

Penso che puoi rilassarti con un po 'della musica che hai qui: https://suonerietelefono.com/ dai la tua musica preferita qui!

At March 12, 2020 at 12:56 AM , Blogger Unknown said...

I love this song. I downloaded it as suonerie for free at suonerietelefono.net

At November 24, 2020 at 3:35 AM , Blogger rishbh91 said...

A customer satisfaction survey is one of the easiest and most reliable methods for getting a snapshot of satisfaction levels around a particular element of your ...

At December 2, 2020 at 12:15 AM , Blogger Aliyah said...

SonneriePro - Adresse fournie sonnerie samsung gratuites, sonnerie telephone iphone, sonnerie sms pour Android, sonnerie portable gratuite.La sonnerie telephone est le moyen le plus merveilleux et le plus complet de transmettre des émotions, nous aidant à ressentir chaque recoin de notre âme.

At December 24, 2020 at 1:27 AM , Blogger Sonidos Mp3 said...

with quality sound effects now sonidos mp3

At March 8, 2021 at 10:08 AM , Blogger sameer said...

Will such things be continued in the years to come. That’s what I’ve been thinking about for a long time. Thank you for this useful information
how to put music on youtube videos without copyright issues
www 4share com
Ines de Ramon
Dababy height
www amazon com mytv
www amazon com mytv

At May 28, 2021 at 6:21 PM , Blogger health said...

I love your article thanks for share the article.

Mp3juice|Romantic period music|Arijit singh song download|Holi song|How to put music on YouTube videos without copyright issues|Movie Box apk|

At June 15, 2021 at 7:49 PM , Blogger jamepoter said...

Your article is really good and besides that I would like to recommend everyone a free
klingeltöne android ringtone site here that has all the hottest songs 2021 and high quality completely free.

At December 20, 2021 at 11:38 PM , Blogger Sandra Jones said...

Changing the font for android devices has never been so easy, font changer for android is proud to be the leading pioneer today.

At April 23, 2022 at 12:53 AM , Blogger Sam Wichky said...

Download peppa pig font at https://yofonts.com/peppa-pig/ absolutely free

At October 19, 2022 at 8:28 PM , Blogger Ghuntran said...

Download free games and apps at xem thêm


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

back to top